Manage Your Subscription Online!

  • Brand new beta site, Dover customers can sign up today!
  • View/edit/add your subscriptions
  • Order upcoming comics
  • View your pull list history
  • View and add new special orders
  • and more!

Subscription Service:

  • We order and hold whatever is on your pull list in your subscription box.
  • Weekly emails detailing new comics are coming out (Optional)
  • Pull list emails whenever we pull comics for you (Optional)

All we need is a $15 refundable deposit and you get your subscribed comics will be bagged and boarded for free. You can also get a free bag and board for any recent comics you pick up from the shelf.


Comics can sit in your box for a maximum of 4 weeks. After 6 weeks, we will remind you to pickup. After 8 weeks we will stop pulling new comics for you. After 10 weeks unless we have heard from you, we will put back your comics and you will forfeit your deposit. If you have a problem and can’t pick up your subscription in a timely fashion, please call us and we will work with you. We can also send you a Paypal invoice and once paid can hold comics indefinitely.

Here is a work-in-progress list of popular comics to get you started, of course you can subscribe to whatever you would like. You can also add something like “everything Spiderman”. Email a list of what you would like to (Dover) or (Middletown)

Action Comics DC Comics
Aquaman DC Comics
Batgirl DC Comics
Batman DC Comics
Batman/Superman DC Comics
Batman and the Outsiders DC Comics
Batman Beyond DC Comics
Books of Magic DC Comics
Catwoman DC Comics
Deathstroke DC Comics
Detective Comics DC Comics
Doom Patrol: Weight of the Worlds DC Comics
The Dreaming DC Comics
The Flash DC Comics
The Green Lantern DC Comics
Harley Quinn DC Comics
Hawkman DC Comics
House of Whispers DC Comics
Justice League DC Comics
Justice League Dark DC Comics
Justice League Odyssey DC Comics
Looney Tunes DC Comics
Lucifer DC Comics
Mad Magazine DC Comics
Nightwing DC Comics
Red Hood and the Outlaws DC Comics
Scooby-Doo, Where Are You? DC Comics
Shazam! DC Comics
Supergirl DC Comics
Superman DC Comics
Teen Titans DC Comics
The Terrifics DC Comics
WildC.A.T.s DC Comics
Wonder Woman DC Comics
Young Justice DC Comics
Aero Marvel Comics
The Amazing Spider-Man Marvel Comics
Avengers Marvel Comics
Black Cat Marvel Comics
Black Panther Marvel Comics
Black Panther and the Agents of Wakanda Marvel Comics
Captain America Marvel Comics
Captain Marvel Marvel Comics
Conan the Barbarian Marvel Comics
Daredevil Marvel Comics
Fantastic Four Marvel Comics
Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man Marvel Comics
Ghost-Spider Marvel Comics
Ghost Rider Marvel Comics
Guardians of the Galaxy Marvel Comics
Immortal Hulk Marvel Comics
Invaders Marvel Comics
Ironheart Marvel Comics
Loki Marvel Comics
Magnificent Ms. Marvel Marvel Comics
Miles Morales: Spider-Man Marvel Comics
The Punisher Marvel Comics
Runaways Marvel Comics
Savage Avengers Marvel Comics
Savage Sword of Conan Marvel Comics
Star Wars Marvel Comics
Star Wars: Doctor Aphra Marvel Comics
Strikeforce Marvel Comics
Superior Spider-Man Marvel Comics
Sword Master Marvel Comics
Tony Stark: Iron Man Marvel Comics
The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl Marvel Comics
Valkyrie: Jane Foster Marvel Comics
Venom Marvel Comics
Doctor Doom Marvel Comics
X-Men Marvel Comics
The Amazing Mary Jane Marvel Comics
Marauders Marvel Comics
Excalibur Marvel Comics
Deadpool Marvel Comics
Fallen Angels Marvel Comics
Morbius Marvel Comics
New Mutants Marvel Comics
Scream: Curse of Carnage Marvel Comics
X-Force Marvel Comics
Iron Man 2020 Marvel Comics
Guardians of the Galaxy Marvel Comics
Thor Marvel Comics
Wolverine Marvel Comics
Flash Forward DC Comics
Inferior Five DC Comics
Harleen DC Comics
The Batman’s Grave DC Comics
Joker/Harley: Criminal Sanity DC Comics
RWBY DC Comics
Metal Men DC Comics
Superman Smashes the Klan DC Comics
Basketful of Heads DC Comics
The Joker: Killer Smile DC Comics